



However, if we were to gain audience feedback in various stages and formats throughout the whole project, this would allow us to reflect and re-evaluate our product at each stage, ensuring we end up creating the best overall product that we possibly could have done. It would also serve to highlight to us any minor flaws or blips in the products that we missed, allowing us to make any appropriate amendments in suitable time before the finished products must be handed in, fine tuning it to create overall professional real media products.
One of the first ways in which we gained feedback was through the initial target audience questionnaire at the beginning of the project. This allowed us to pitch our rough ideas for our video to our target audience, and to receive feedback in terms of their opinions on our plans. Receiving feedback at this stage let us sample how successful the concept would be in theory, giving us plenty of time to refine the idea before we began filming. Luckily, most of the feedback we received at this stage was fairly positive. This told us that we were on the right track with our products, and allowed us to continue developing our ideas safe in the knowledge that the basic premise would be relatively successful and well received.
One piece of negative feedback that we received for the music video at this stage was that the plot line seemed quite unclear so far. We felt this was a fair enough comment, as we were not entirely sure what we were aiming for or hoping to achieve at that point, so we took this on board as constructive criticism, ironing out a basic comprehensible plot line and and narrative to make the video easier to follow.
We were constantly asking members of our media group for feedback throughout the entire editing process of our video - for example asking their opinions on certain shots, transitions or effects, which we could then reflect upon and take on board on the spot. This active involvement with the target audience allowed us to constantly be working to improve our products throughout the whole process. Once we had finished a rough cut of our final music video, we devised a shot questionnaire to assess the success of our product. We asked a number of participants from different age ranges and genders to feedback their opinions of the product, which allowed us to see if there were any final improvements we could make to ensure we created the best product we could. Some of the positive feedback we received at this stage included liking the way the representations of the conventions of the genre, as well as a certain level of empathy with the characters. This showed us that we had the right ideas in the creation of our video, and had succeeded in the representations we had hoped to convey.
In addition to the feedback for the music video, we thought it would be beneficial to gain a number of feedback concerning the ancillary texts. Initially, we showed rough sketches of our ideas to members of our target audience, who pointed out sections they liked - including the fact that the cover defied conventions by being from behind, and the cohesion of the costume and mise-en-scene in line with the musical genre. This showed us that we did not have to change anything in this respect as we were clearly on track with conveying the ideas about our genre and impressions.
Some negative feedback we received at this stage was that they did not seem to like the writing on the arm that we intended to use as the text style on our CD cover. We took this on board and started to plan different styles in which we could incorporate this onto our CD cover in a more visually pleasing manner.
These are some of the questions we asked for the evaluation of these products:
The sepia effect also proved to come in useful in the earlier flashback scenes of the Scrabble playing, as it made the lighting seem more natural and overall enhanced the poor lighting. This also allowed us to slightly increase the brightness and contrast of these clips, making them more visible and defined, whilst not causing any suffering to the overall visual quality of the images.
We additionally wanted to represent the flashbacks in a more obvious way, in order to create cohesion between our product and the audience, as we found that this could often be confusing when we showed the video in various stages of completion to members of our target audience. We had hoped to do this in the conventional way of a short, clear flash effect, however, when experimenting with this effect on iMovie, we found that our clips were to sure to apply the effect to, and therefore had to find an alternative. We experimented with the overlapping effect, blending the two images together in one frame, however again as the clip was fairly short, it created a freeze frame at the end of the transition, which disrupted the smooth, flowing visuals of the video and created a really obvious jarring in the comfortable reception a sleeker style allows. Eventually, we decided on the 'White In' effect, which is basically a fade in from a whit background as opposed to black. We feel this effectively represented the 'flash' idea that we were hoping to achieve but in a more effective, and smoother style, synonymous with the pace of the song.
We showed the video to one of our media teachers, who provided us with some useful feedback. She picked up on the section toward the beginning that we had been concerned about - the scene leading in to the flashback. She felt that it would perhaps be worthwhile trying to find a substitute clip to replace the short and abrupt clips that we had been left with. We took this on board and found a discarded shot of a pan across the Scrabble box. We removed the rapid shot-reverse-shot that showed her reaction to the box, and instead replaced it with a clip of this shot, which served to act as a point of view shot. This clip slotted perfectly into the timings of the previous succession of clips, thereby not creating any dramatic effect on the timings of the rest of the video, and allowing a much smoother and more comfortable transition into the flashback scenes.
We added a long fade out effect at the end of the video to keep in line with the more conventional aspect of the image we wanted to portray, and also to heighten the stereotypical generic feature of the 'happy ending', as a fade implies much more gentle and softened connotations than perhaps an abrupt cut at the end may signify. We additionally added a short fade to the beginning of our video primarily in order to contain the titles that we were required to included on our video, but iMovie would not allow us to use these two effects simultaneously. We overcame this slightly by dragging and dropping the title effect onto the opening clip, which added the titles - we decided to keep these basic and simplistic, with the artist and track names being the only information we chose to include, in order to best represent the more simplistic style of the artist and indeed the music itself. We decided to keep the fade in at the beginning anyway, as it created a much gentler beginning to the start of the video, in line with the soft instrumental beginnings of the start of the song.
Now we have finished our video, we will next save it onto the external hard drive for backup purposes, and burn it onto a DVD for the examiners.
We then went on to create this sheet for use as inserts into the booklet. Again, very little editing was used here in order to keep the running visual theme of an almost rustic like naturalism. We selected these shots as they are close-ups that emphasise certain parts of the females body, but not in a typically sexualised way, in light of the male gaze theory. They instead serve as flattering shots that allow a certain element of connection and familiarity to be established with the artist in a way that defies the usual rules of the straight staring gaze down the lens of a camera. We liked these two images as we felt that the colourings in them accentuated the feel of naturalism we were hoping to portray. The image on the right hand side did not turn out to be a successful as we had hoped - it was originally quite a dark image, so we used various tools in Photoshop in an attempt to amend this, however it still turned out much darker than we had envisioned when printed out. If we had had more time on this day, we would have perhaps devoted a little more attention into editing this image in order for it to create maximum impact and reach it's full potential. We originally planned to combine these images opposite a black lyrics page, however we felt that we wanted to stick to the idea of simplicity we had adhered to throughout the creation of all of our products, and thought it would have more of an impact left to itself, further emphasising the idea of mystery and the story line behind the images.
I personally quite like this image. I feel that the use of natural lighting in the form of the sun is fairly effective, as it accentuates all the colours and tones of the image, making it more aesthetically pleasing as well as playing to the generic conventions. The way her hair is tousled by the breeze conveys the pretty young girl image that we were aiming for in representations. This image is highly unconventional for this genre as you can't see the girls face. Normally, there would be a close up shot of the girl with particular emphasis on her face, in order to promote her image and create a sense of recognition and familiarity with the audience. As you cannot see her face here, it creates an element of mystery, perhaps adding music more of a dynamic to the product and subsequently the artist. This image poses the question of why she is facing away from the camera, and where she is going or the significance of what she is looking towards. There is no evidence of male gaze theory, and the image is not sexualised in any way - in fact there is minimal focus on the female form, as the guitar dominated most of the foreground, perhaps implying that the music is more important than the image of the artist, very much in line with typical folk music values. I think this image would work effectively as an album cover, as is both a conventional and unconventional representation on the artist and the genre, which makes for an interesting narrative behind the image, creating a story that is deciphered entirely by the audience. I don't think we would have to do much by means of editing to this image, apart from perhaps cropping it, and using slight effects to enhance the image to it's full potential - adding the slightest bit of contrast for example in order to bring out the colourings of the image more. Furthermore, it would create the right level of cohesion between the narrative and the CD cover, as it is not an image sourced directly from the narrative, but there are still many visible connections that would be able to seamlessly link the products together.
This shot may be quite effective to use inside our CD package, perhaps as an inlay or inside to booklet. It is a shot Hannah took at home of Scrabble tiles, spelling out the words 'More Than Friends'. This serves to create a strong visual link and cohesion with the name of the track and the ancillary product that we choose to use this image on. The dim lighting in this shot extends the feeling of romanticism that we were trying to achieve in this scene, emphasising it's effect and reinforcing the synergy between products.
COSTUMES:
To promote continuity throughout our video, we have asked the actors to bring the same costumes as they wore for the flashback scene before, i.e. when playing scrabble. For Beth, this outfit consisted of a red checkered shirt, dark jeans and red trainers. For Oscar, this consisted of a red vest, dark jeans and trainers. These outfits expand on and emphasise the happier connotations of the narrative with this scene, particularly through the usage of colour connotations.
LOCATION:
We plan to film in Victoria Park, a large park roughly a ten minute walk away from college. I live close by, so this means if we are unable to return to college after filming, I would be able to take the borrowed equipment home safely. Additionally, this means that I know the park well, and should theoretically be able to suggest suitable locations for filming.
PROPS:
As one of the key themes running through the narrative of these scenes is simplicity, we do not require any props. The emphasis will be strongly on the couple, enjoying each others company and spending time together. I will, however, need to bring the guitar again. As well as finishing all of our filming today, we plan to capture the rest of the images we need for the ancillary products, including the images of Beth alone to be used for the CD cover and the magazine advert. This also means we will need to bring our digital cameras to capture the images on, as well as borrowing the camcorders and the tripod from college again.
ACTORS:
Hannah has contacted the actors and confirmed that they are available from tomorrow lunchtime onwards, which allows us the double period at the end of the day as well as a little extra time after college should we run over the planned filming time again.
After the initial awkwardness of the first scene, the two seemed to act quite comfortably together, which we felt would help to enhance the feeling of realism we aim to achieve in our representation.
We used framing here to represent the emotional detachment between the couple. Whilst they were lying in bed, we wanted the closeup shots to be framed heavily-weighted to one side, surrounding the character with empty space in the frame, in reflection of the vast amount of space between the couple on an emotional as well as physical basis. This was something we then emphasised with an overhead mid-shot of the two in bed, where each was positioned as far from their opposing sides of the frame as possible, showing a clear physical divide between the two, which connotes the status of their relationship.
Setting up for these scenes took much longer than we had imagined, but this showed us what to expect for the rest of the filming period, allowing us to factor this in to the time management for the remainder of the day.
Kuda's room was quite small and with 5 people in it, the room became quite cramped. There was not a massive deal of room for manoeuvre, and so we had to be quite experimental and creative with the angles and shots we chose. One problem we encountered was the natural light from outside, which kept fluctuating from brightness to darkness due to the cloudy weather. This affected the continuity of the shots, and meant that we had to shoot double the amount we had expected to try and get a range of clips that would enable us to create a running visual theme, instead of a disruptive, constantly changing visual flow between shots.
Additionally, as the natural light from the window was the only lighting source we used, we had to be very careful in the positioning of ourselves and the camera, so as not to cast any shadows across the scene. This meant that we took a number of unconventional filming approaches into obtaining the angling we needed, including placing the tripod above the actors in the bed, and also holding it out to create an overhead mid-shot of the two together. The only way in which we could effectively achieve this was to sit at the foot of the bed, with all three of us holding the end of the tripod in order to get as steady a shot as possible. Obviously, this was going to affect the outcome of the shot, as it would not ensure complete stability, but it would make for a smoother visual style than a simple hand held shot might have done.
We filmed a few brief shots of the mise-en-scene that we brought, but I feel that we are unlikely to use them as there was nowhere they could be positioned to be simply seen in the background, and quick pan across them may look odd and out of context.
We then went into the dining room to film the second set of interior shots. This was fairly easy to set up, as we had already seen the location through images Kuda had shown us, and upon entering the house, so we had a rough idea of the camera set up we wanted to use. Additionally, there was much more room for movement whilst filming, so we were able to get a wider variety of camera angles and positions. Seeing as we had three cameras, we thought it would be best to have at least one set up in a static, long to mid shot setting,in order to allow a steady and clear depiction of the narrative. We used the remaining two cameras to gain alternative angles and perspectives, focusing on one character each. This would enable us to create a range of camera effects in the editing stages, such as that of the shot-reverse-shot between the two characters, and match-on-action's, for example, when the glass of juice is passed across the table. In the modern day, main narrative to the video, we opted for the use of more high angles shots, to show a more powerless and weaker position, in order to reflect the state of the relationship that we wanted to convey. It makes the two seem as though they have no power to change anything within the relationship, and they are emotionally sinking together. In the happier flashbacks, we made a point to capture many of the shots from a lower angle, looking up at the two actors. This heightens a feeling of authority and power, perhaps suggesting that they are on top of their relationship and in total control - it is unfolding as they want it to, and they are both of a mutual level of respect and understanding in the relationship.
One problem that we encountered during this part of the filming process was again with the lighting in scenes, particularly that of the flashback. We wanted this scene to come across as romantic and intimate, and were hoping to achieve this through the use of low-key lighting in the form of candles. However, when we began to film like this, we noticed that the shots were far too dark, and the camera wasn't picking up any images in great quality. We tried to resolve this by opening the curtains behind us slightly, in order to filter a small amount of light in to act as a front light, allowing the camera to pick up the image. However, the natural light was too powerful, and completely overturned the lighting from the candles. Additionally, as we framed the shot with a window separating the two, and were filming during the day, the only way to block out this light was to pull the curtain across it. However, this failed to stop the light from seeping through the edges of the curtain and ruing the effect of the shot. We overcame this slightly by placing the lid of the Scrabble box against the curtain to hold it down, but unfortunately it was ultimately unavoidable. We set about trying to find a range of different shots to avoid seeing the lighting, usually using close ups that focused more on the face or action at hand.
Whilst we were filming, we also thought it would be beneficial to hold various photoshoots at the same time. These images could then be used for our ancillary products of the magazine advert and the CD digipack. By taking images simultaneous to our filming, it would create cohesion between the images, as the factors of the images would all be the same, in terms of location, appearance, lighting etc. This is an important thing to consider when thinking about the synergy we need to create through our digipack, in order for it to work together as a whole promotional tool.
These are some of the images we captured. Although we did not make any plans for any images of this sort, we thought it would be beneficial to us to get as wide a range of images as possible, whether planned or impromptu like these were.
We then left the interior location, and walked to a park close to Kuda's house. The weather was pretty miserable by this point, which could have worked well in terms of the connotations of misery we were aiming to portray in the narrative, but overall we felt that it would be better to come back and film more exterior shots another day. Unfortunately, due to the extensive amount of filming we had done all day, the cameras were nearly flat, and so we did not have much filming time left as it was. We managed to film a fair number of exterior shots in this location, before it started to rain, so it may even be the case that we have enough of the modern day narrative strand as it is. We will definitely need to arrange another day to film the exterior flashback scenes, hopefully on a day with a more desirable weather forecast.